Thursday, April 18, 2013

Sociology Week 10

This week we talked about how the media negatively affects girls' body images of themselves. Girls are always being bombarded with images of very conventionally "beautiful" women. Women who are thin with virtually no flaws. The crazy thing is that these women girls are looking up to usually aren't even real. Thanks to our ability to transform images, the models and celebrities we see don't appear as purely themselves. These women have their own flaws too- like Britney Spears' cellulite that was taken away- we just don't see them. We watched the movie "Killing us Softly 4". This movie talked about all of these points in detail. The only thing I didn't like about it was how it portrayed thinness. I am someone who is naturally thin and I feel like the way the woman presented it in the video wasn't right. She showed pictures of very thin models to shock the audience at how thin girls are becoming. Although I agree it's very bad that girls who aren't naturally that thin are aspiring to be, it also needs to be recognized in the media's new movement against promoting being too thin that it's okay to be thin if that is your body type. I think the message should be to be healthy through eating well and getting exercise and whatever body you end up with through being healthy, is beautiful. For some girls that's bigger, for some it's just "perfect", and for some it's more on the thin side. Similarly, I don't think it's fair for campaigns like Dove to only feature women above a certain size, or for some companies to only hire models above a certain weight. I think that in order to promote all natural body types as beautiful, all women, sizes 0 and above, should be featured as models. As bad as it is to only feature models who are a size 0, I think it's just as bad to exclude them completely.

2 comments:

  1. I agree that the issue should be about health. I also agree that there should be a range or spectrum of different body types - in the media, in dolls, on mannequins etc... In defense of killing us softly, I think the models who were super thin were considered unhealthy - some had eating disorders and one died. That is unhealthily thin. It's too bad the speaker didn't focus more on the girls health and less on their size.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. While many of them were unhealthily thin and clearly sickly looking, some were just thin. Some looked like me and other girls I know. Since I don't know those models I can't say whether or not that is their natural body type or whether or not they made that their body through unhealthy means. But I think society is ignorant in assuming that girls who are thinner than average have an eating disorder.

      Delete